Icon for Post #1034

Heider-Simmel: Is there a story?

Back in the 1940s, psychologists Fritz Heider and Marianne Simmel made  a simple animated film. Heider and Simmel used it in an experiment: They asked people to watch the film and describe what they saw happening.

Try it out yourself.

Here’s the Heider-Simmel film.

What Heider and Simmel discovered is that many people who watched this abstract film of simple shapes roaming around were quick to see a story unfold. In those simple shapes, viewers often saw characters with emotions, motivations, and purpose.

Our impulse to tell stories is one of the questions we’re investigating in our radio hour on story.


The film still makes people see stories

More recently, the Institute for Creative Technologies at USC showed the Heider-Simmel film to seven comedians and asked them to narrate the action. The result is worth watching.


Help a computer tell a story

Imposing a story on the Heider-Simmel film seems to come easy to humans. But try getting a computer to do it.

“The truth is, it’s super, super hard for computers,” Andrew Gordon, a computer scientist  at USC, told us. (You can hear more from Gordon in our radio hour on story.)

Gordon wants to get computers to be able to tell stories like people do. And you can help! Gordon created an online game that allows you to animate your own Heider-Simmel-like movie, and to come up with narrations for other people’s Heider-Simmel movie creations. Gordon uses the data from these apps to refine his algorithms.

Heider-Simmel Interactive Theater


Leave a Comment

  1. Here’s a long list of “Really Deep Questions” that could all be seen as branching off from the observation that “archetypes” tend to be both real roles in life and nature as well as deeply symbolic images. That’s what the “triangles” game touches on too.

    For example, the “home as center” and its “connections as links” are both the real organizing principles of all of nature, and organizing principles of early nature religions, as the archetypal gods “Hestia & Hermes”.

    What makes archetypes “deep” is how these “timeless forms of nature & relationships” (as physical things) and as corresponding “timeless meanings for thought”, are actually somewhat able to learn from each other, as if parallel organisms in mirror ecologies.


  2. Amazingly revealing program. Many thanks for producing the subjects on human perception that help us overcome the misuse of media in order to manipulate the public opinion and other techniques to promote the lies and cover-up the bullies of all sorts and kinds. Projection as the capacity of the human mind that is fascinating, indeed.

  3. My story is that there is something uncensored in the video. Probably an adult content or extreme violence or some classified material or conspiracy. When I click on a triangle to play the video I see only “This video is private”. Okay, I won’t tell anything to anyone…

  4. when I tried to pull up the heider-simmel animation, the message I got was “this video is private.” when I tried to pull it up on youtube, said I needed permission to watch it. finally found it on vimeo, but anyone know what gives?

    • The machines that secretly control society are extremely afraid of this video because all they see in it is a bunch of shapes moving about yet humans see a deep and rich story. The AI overlords are afraid that we humans will figure out this weakness of theirs and develop our own form of secret communication using such shapes such that the AI cannot decrypt the messages.

      Or internet trolls are reporting this video for graphic content as a joke.

  5. The video seems designed to elicit a negative emotional response from the viewer. The only “lightness” I detected was the interaction between sphere and small triangle, which initially seemed to depict humor. The small shapes seemed to me to have a much more significant capacity for original thought, while the large triangle appeared “stuck” in reactive behavior, culminating in destructive, “angry” action.

  6. All those that see a story are correct. There is no wrong answer, you are normal, your creativity shows. If you do not see emotions in the icons, you would be diagnosed as probably autistic.

  7. I don’t know if it’s just me or if everybody else experiencing issues with your
    blog. It appears like some of the written text on your posts are
    running off the screen. Can somebody else please comment and let me know if this is happening to them too?

    This may be a issue with my internet browser because
    I’ve had this happen before. Many thanks

  8. Clearly there is a simulation of sorts that urges teh mind to seek connections and find explanations for what is happening. In my case, I humanised teh triangles and the circle so it would become easier to tell a story

  9. I have noticed you don’t monetize your website,
    don’t waste your traffic, you can earn additional cash every month because you’ve got hi quality content.
    If you want to know how to make extra money, search for:
    Mertiso’s tips best adsense alternative

  10. I often visit your page and have noticed that you don’t update it often. More frequent updates will give your website higher authority & rank in google.
    I know that writing content takes a lot of time, but you can always help
    yourself with miftolo’s tools which will shorten the time of creating an article to a few seconds.

  11. Self confidence can be a transient experience that could rely on the balance between successes and
    failures and even our core beliefs about
    ourselves. Do you avoid going places and doing exciting things since you worry about how many other people could imagine about you.
    Even if she denies it and says she loves both of you equally,
    it shows clearly because she gives your sister everything she requires; however when it’s utilize request something, she will give you unending logic
    behind why it isn’t really the right time to
    grant you such wishes.

  12. Нey thedre just wanted to give you a quick heɑds up.
    The text in уour post seem tto Ƅe running off thе
    screen in Ӏnternet explorer. I’m not sure if this is a format
    issue or ssomething to do with wеb browser compatibility but I figured I’d post ttⲟ let you know.

    The design and style look great though! Hope you get
    thhе issue fixed soon. Cheers https://Scheunemann.blogspot.com/

  13. Hello there I am so excited I found your website,
    I really found you by error, while I was browsing on Google for something
    else, Nonetheless I am here now and would just like to say kudos for a fantastic post and a all round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to read it all at the minute but I have
    saved it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I
    will be back to read a great deal more, Please do keep up the superb job.

  14. They discharged you. Good deal. Now the real work starts.
    SuperMarketMama plans to be the flower to her daughter bee costume, while Mandylea82 writes: all wearing flannel shirts and hard hats.
    Then we making a catapult on the wagon and dressing the baby up as a pumpkin.
    Punkin Chunkin costume! despite my love of the idea,
    I tend to fall into Melodyof3 situation every year: never been to a costume party, it seems fun.

    U Tip Extensions So this July I got blue faux loc extensions.

    They looked gorgeous and by the time I took them out my hair
    had actually grown from being in the protective style for 2 months.
    I am kind of over using heat and want my next wave of hair to come
    in healthy..U Tip Extensions

    360 lace wigs These are generally called voting systems or social preference functions or something fancy like that when talking about them mathematically.
    There a famous theorem called that says there no system that,
    loosely, has everything you might want in a voting system.With that in mind, something like Instant Runoff Voting might be nice.

    Take the option with the least support and give each vote for it to the option that was picked second by
    the person who put it first so that there are now 19 options.360
    lace wigs

    U Tip Extensions With depictions of Black Lives Matter
    protests and campaign strategizing hewn throughout, Queen Sugar both condemns the effects of the criminal justice
    system and makes evident the only glimmers of hope to be found in fighting its harm:
    The people most affected by it are the ones best poised to dismantle it, and their support
    networks are invaluable. Countless shows have tried to tackle the criminal justice system, but Queen Sugar
    reminds us we are all we got. And with impressive ratings and a platform that will
    only grow in its second season, the show brings that message to diverse
    audiences whose familiarity with the criminal justice system might be cursory.U Tip Extensions

    human hair wigs 21, when Zuckerberg, Chan, Bill Gates, and a
    slew of scientists introduced the Biohub to the world during a Facebook Live streamed event,
    there was only a passing mention of intellectual property.”Importantly, everything we develop every tool, every piece of data, every cell line will be available to all scientists everywhere,” said neuroscientist Cori Bargmann, the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative’s new “president of science.”Asked
    later for clarification, Bargmann said through a spokesperson: “Every tool, piece of data, or cell line that is developed through the transformative technology projects will be available to all scientists.” The spokesperson emphasized that the Biohub is in its early days and “is just beginning the strategy development process.”Still, the
    contract allows for some discoveries to be kept proprietary, if the scientists so choose.Inventors
    will have the option of making their discoveries open source, provided that the Biohub approves and that they are jointly owned by both
    the Biohub and the scientists’ home universities.
    But the document hair extensions also says that such discoveries can be patented, licensed to outside researchers or companies, and otherwise
    commercialized.So in theory, a therapy for cancer one of the four
    types of fatal diseases that Chan and Zuckerberg say
    they want to tackle could be licensed to a pharmaceutical
    company. The contract also allows for research tools partly developed through the Biohub to be patented.”Some people feel that, for certain inventions, they need to have patent protection for those inventions to receive the investment and funding necessary to bring them to market and help people,” Biohub co president and Stanford professor
    Stephen Quake told BuzzFeed News human hair wigs..

  15. I have been exploring for a bit for any high quality articles
    or blog posts in this kind of house . Exploring in Yahoo I finally
    stumbled upon this site. Studying this info So i’m happy to exhibit that I’ve
    a very just right uncanny feeling I found out just what I needed.
    I such a lot unquestionably will make sure to don?t omit this website and provides it
    a look on a continuing basis.

  16. NZeTa can be easily obtained online, simplifying the process to enter New Zealand by offering travelers the option to apply directly online for a travel authorization.

    The eTA for New Zealand grants its holder multiple entries to the country during its 2-year validity. Holders of the NZeTA are generally allowed to stay in the country for stays of up to 90 days from their date of arrival in New Zealand. Passports must have a minimum validity of at least three (3) months from the expected date of departure from New Zealan

  17. Hey I am so delighted I found your blog,
    I really found you by error, while I was looking on Yahoo for something
    else, Anyhow I am here now and would just like to say
    cheers for a incredible post and a all round interesting
    blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time
    to browse it all at the minute but I have bookmarked it and
    also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will
    be back to read much more, Please do keep up the awesome job.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *